[blml] Belgian TD exam question
Alain Gottcheiner
agot at ulb.ac.be
Tue Nov 7 13:53:29 CET 2006
>
>
>North is bound to Law 53 A:
>"Any lead faced out of turn may be treated
>as a correct lead. It becomes a correct lead
>[...] if the player next in rotation [...] plays to
>the irregular lead [...]"
>In this law there's nothing about "irrationally
>plays to the irregular play" or the like.
>So, NS get the table score while for the
>declarer we apply Law 72 B1 as he did
>gain through the irregularity.
We need to be more precise. Gaining from the irregularity isn't enough to
adjust the score if serendipitous. L72B1 applies when serendipity may not
be assumed.
Best regards
Alain.
More information about the blml
mailing list