[blml] L20F1

[David Barton]

                      AQ954
                      Q
                      52
                      AQ762

10                                    J7
109762                            A853
9864                                A1073
983                                  J105

                       K8632
                       KJ4
                       KQJ
                       K4

W     N      E        S
                            1S
P      4D     P        4H
P      4N     P       5D
P      6S     all pass

opening lead C8 result N-S +1430

Before the opening lead W asked about the auction and
was informed by N ONLY that
4D showed a raise to at least 4S with good  trumps
4H showed a H control
4N also showed a H control
5D showed a D control

It subsequently emerged that S thought 4N was RKCB
and that 5D showed 1 or 4 key cards.

If we accept that N's explanations were correct and that
once reminded S said nothing because correct explanations
had been given, is there any grounds for a score adjustment.

If the explanations had been given in accordance with the 
"...normally be given by the partner.." requirement of L20F1,
then Souths misunderstanding would have emerged, and a
red suit lead MAY have been selected.

What are your views?  

*****************************************
  david.j.barton at lineone.net
*****************************************



-- 
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.431 / Virus Database: 268.14.8/539 - Release Date: 19/11/2006 19:10