[blml] Law 12A1 and Law 12B

[Alain Gottcheiner]

At 11:15 11/10/2006 +0200, Peter Eidt wrote:


>Try this one ...
>
>       7
>       84
>       (3)
>       J7
>
>J6           --
>5             93
>--             Q8
>632         K9
>
>       98
>       --
>       10
>       AQ10
>
>South is declarer in 4 spades and has lost 1 trick.
>East to lead plays the DQ.
>West ruffs with the J and when South asks
>dummy to play a club the diamond 3 appears
>from behind the C7. TD !

I'd say this is one easy.

1. All players are responsible for not noticing dummy has too few cards. No 
redress to anyone for that.
2. Dummy doesn't revoke and has no penalty card. Substitute D3 for C7. End.

Regards

   Alain