[blml] Only unanimous comments please.

[Adam Beneschan]

Tony wrote:
 
> OK, this occurred so recently that I remember it.
> However, I only remember that there were some
> contrary opinions, so I can't remember the
> "consensus".
> 
> A fellow director has asked me the following:
> 
>                             S   --
>                             H   9 5
>                             D   5
>                             C  --
> 
> S  8
> H  7
> D  6
> C --
> 
>                              S  5
>                              H  10
>                              D  --
>                              C  Q
> 
> three cards are left, hearts are trumps, declarer
> leads the club Q intending to discard the diamond
> 5 from dummy. However, West ruffs and declarer
> calls five..oh! 9 of hearts..all in one breath.
> 
> I'm not allowing the change, so I only want
> supporting arguments please.  And the same if
> he calls diam..oh!9 of hearts.
> 
> OK?

No comment.

                                -- Adam