[blml] Law 45D - Was card misplayed by Dummy?

[Matthias Berghaus]

I do not think that a card is played because declarer thinks it should 
be played. The laws are clear about the conditions for a card to be 
played. I _do_ think that it would be nice to make declarer play a card 
he thought he would play, but since I cannot for the life of me find a 
way to do that consistently I would rather stick to the current situation.

Herman De Wael schrieb:
> raija wrote:
>
>   
>> I don't know who the eight posters are that you mention.  They must have 
>> emailed you directly. 
>>
>>     
>
>   

snipped

> Matthias Berghaus wrote:
>  > There is no doubt in my mind that every director wants a declarer who
>  > doesn`t know what the contract is to pay for that, as every 
> director is
>  > also a player, and players are pissed off when opp does something 
> stupid
>  > and gets away with it.
>