[blml] Marvin French's Procedures for handling UI - part one [SEC=UNOFFICIA

[Herman De Wael]

Tim West-Meads wrote:
> 
> As has been argued here before "Among the white sheep were a goat and a 
> black ram - when asked to choose his favourite animal the farmer 
> selected the goat."
> 
> For Goat read "Illogical Alternative", for black ram read "Suggested LA" 
> for sheep read "Non-suggested LAs".  Thus it is linguistically possible 
> to select an IA from among LAs.  This interpretation is consistent with 
> the words of L16a2 "When a player has substantial reason to believe that 
> an opponent who had a logical alternative..".  It is the existence of 
> LAs which matters - not the logicality of the selected action.  Only 
> white sheep are legal!
> 

No Tim, the goat is legal!
only the black ram is the suggested alternative and cannot be chosen.

> Tim
> 

-- 
Herman DE WAEL
Antwerpen Belgium
http://www.hdw.be