[blml] R馭. : Re: DeWael School and WBFLC [SEC=UNOFFICIAL]

[Robert Geller]

Give me a break!!!

L73B1 reads as follows
**********************************************
B. Inappropriate Communication Between Partners 
1. Gratuitous Information 
Partners shall not communicate through the manner in which calls or plays are made, through extraneous 
remarks or gestures, through questions asked or not asked of the opponents or through alerts and 
explanations given or not given to them. 
******************************************

This says you can't use an answer to a question to deliberately communicate info
to partner.   It doesn't in any way say you are relieved of the obligation to answer 
questions about your agreements like a pre-programmed robot, which is what the
laws require.

-Bob

Alain Gottcheiner さんは書きました:
>At 02:27 5/06/2007 +0900, Robert Geller wrote:
>>Sorry if I think Herman's point is not well-taken.
>>Law 20 apllies (you have to explain your agreements), and
>>Law73C also applies (partner has to avoid using the UI from
>>your correct explanation of the system).
>
>The problem is, L73B1 applies also.
>

-----------------------------------------------------
Robert (Bob) Geller,     Tokyo, Japan        geller at nifty.com