[blml] adjudication

[Todd M. Zimnoch]

Tim West-Meads wrote:
> Any attempt to regulate bidding by mandating a mechanical approach (e.g 
> HCP, Ro19 etc) would be restrictive of judgement - and thus against the 
> laws of bridge.  As such I actually bothered to enquire of the EBU as to 
> whether their regulations were illegal and, on being assured that the 
> regulations were legal, concluded that they were not supposed to be 
> treated mechanically.

If the question you're interested in is whether the 
regulation is enforced mechanically or not, why didn't you 
ask that question of the EBU?

You may be right in your conclusion, but the method seems 
untoward.

-Todd