[blml] Are the laws clear on telling pard to ask a question?

[Wayne Burrows]

On 16/03/07, Eric Landau <ehaa at starpower.net> wrote:
> At 02:36 AM 3/15/07, Jerry wrote:
>
> >Sorry if I was unclear. The director was fully aware of the correct
> >procedure and timing of questions and face-down leads.  He even told
> >East that it was not her turn to ask questions.  There he was perfect.
> >
> >It was his next ruling I find troubling:  He felt that the instant
> >West asked East's question, his job was done, so he left and did not
> >return.
> >
> >I challenge BLMLers to go through that in silence and without raising
> >an eyebrow.  (I failed, though I was silent.  Well, maybe I said
> >"Huh?")  I would be impressed if any BLMLers are sure they would do
> >it.
>
> I would have asked East to select her opening lead, and instructed
> South to answer West's question after the lead was on the table.  I
> might also warn East against using any potential UI from the fact of
> West having asked the question.
>
> If challenged, I would point out that, per L41B, West has committed an
> "error in procedure" for which no specific rectification is provided,
> and I am therefore carrying out my duty per L82A.

L82A constrains you to make rulings that are not contrary to the laws.
 L20F2 gives the opening leader the right to ask a question.  I do not
think you can forbid that question without breaking the requirements
of L82A.

Wayne