[blml] Split score

[Sven Pran]

> On Behalf Of Laszlo Hegedus
> Hi, suppose after a long auction East-West reach 4S. During the bidding
> there was an agreed MI: East misinformed North about one of his
> partner's bid. The MI drives North to sacrifice 5H which is doubled and
> goes down 2, the 4S would have been down 2 as well. With correct
> information North would surely pass instead of sacrifice (and the 4S-2
> is the very likely result). If you are the TD, you see North's hand and
> decides if the sacrifice is reasonable or clearly bad bridge with the
> received information.
> 
> #1 If the sacrifice is reasonable. You adjust  4S-2.
> 
> #2 If the sacrifice seems really bad with the MI as well, then result
> 5H*-2 stands and give a procedural penalty to the OS.
> 
> #3 If the sacrifice is reasonable, but for example during the play the
> declarer goes down once more then he should have, you adjust a split
> score.
> 
> Am I right? Is there any quite different situation when split score is
> adjusted? E.g. is it possible to adjust a split score in #2?

Sure, rather than giving a procedure penalty I would seriously consider
letting the table result (5HX-2) stand for North/South and adjust to 4S-2
for East/West only.

Regards Sven