[blml] Obviously this is the prime duty

[Matthias Berghaus]

Steve Willner schrieb:
>
> While anyone can see a difference between these (Answering vs. volunteering information), they are both covered 
> by "in any manner."

Steve, if I _answer_ a question (which I am compelled by law to do), or 
if I _volunteer_ information (which I do willingly), would you say it is 
the same? Of course both may give UI, but (as the WBFLC tells us, see 
CoP) if I do so _without design_, being forced by law to do so, I commit 
no infraction. So if I commit no infraction by answering truthfully, but 
I commit an infraction by lying, which shall it be? Partner is not 
allowed to use UI in any case.
>   Thus for the purpose under discussion, it is far 
> from obvious that the "rather large difference" actually matters in 
> bridge Law.
>
>
>