[blml] The sixth sick sheik's sixth sheep is sick [SEC=UNOFFICIAL]

[Robert Geller]

Herman De Wael さんは書きました:
>
>Bob, your post is totally off the rails. For several reasons. Let me 
>enumerate:

I respectfully disagree.  

L75C says I'm obligated to disclose partnership agreements and partnership
experience.  According to Richard's conditions we've played old-fashioned
blackwood for many years with no errors.  Thus as our agreement is 
simple Blackwood and we have never before had an error. L75 requires
me to reply "3 aces."   

I recognize this may not feel right, but c'est la vie.  I wish Hermann would
suggest how he proposes L75 should be revised to make it (in his opinion)
more equitable, rather than merely advocating that we arbitrarily violate the
law when it "feels right" to do so.

>Again, which laws do you want us to not break?
Creating UI only is subject to score
adjustment if the UI creates a situation where pard could have been adjudged
to have based a subsequent call on the UI.  So I don't see any problem at all
in the Blackwood case.

-Bob 

-----------------------------------------------------
Robert (Bob) Geller,     Tokyo, Japan        geller at nifty.com