[blml] Is investigation needed after this incident? [SEC=UNOFFICIAL]

[Alain Gottcheiner]

Sven Pran a écrit :
>> Harald Skjæran a écrit :
>>     
>>> In a similar way a Norwegian relay pair had these agreements:
>>>
>>> 3C=I've forgotten the system, please place the contract.
>>> 3D=You've forgotten the system, I'll place the contract next round.
>>>
>>>       
>> IMNSHO, the 3D bid is illegal, because how could the player know his
>> partner had forgotten the system, other than through his explanations,
>> which are UI ?
>> (barring the exceptional case when the player made a bid that doesn't
>> exiqst in the system)
>>     
>
> What makes you think that the "exceptional case" was not the actual case leading to a 3D bid?
>   

Because this happens too uncommonly to make a recovery mechanism at the 
3-level necessary just for this.
In my system, there is exactly one non-existent bid below this level  
[1C (2C nat) 2NT]
I meant "exceptional", you see.