[blml] (pas de sujet)

[Alain Gottcheiner]

gesta at tiscali.co.uk a écrit :
> Just to double check that we are now in total agreement. 2D
> opening - 1H undercall. 1H is artificial showing a balanced
> 13-17. Replaced with 2NT showing a balanced 15-17
> (assume this is OK for the sake of the example).
>
> i) responder raises to game with his 10 count. Game makes.
> The overcaller has only 13 points. Outcome; they've got lucky
> - score stands.
>
> ii) responder passes with his 10 count. Game doesn't make.
> Outcome; regardless of whether the overcaller has his bid or
> not, the score is adjusted to game going off.
>
>   
AG : don't agree. At the moment the player decided to bid 1H, he decided 
his hand was worth 15. So the adjustment shouldn't be on the basis of 
"help from the IB", but on "fielded the underbid, had a CPU that 1H was 
in fact less than announced".