[blml] SF Non-NABC Appeal 8

Guthrie guthrie at ntlworld.com
Sun Feb 3 14:29:23 CET 2008


<http://web2.acbl.org/casebooks/SanFrancisco2007/Non-NABC+08.pdf>
I sympathise a little with EW. We are informed that they are a new 
partnership and NS had five times more masterpoints. At the appeal, I 
feel that, had West taken advice or had more experience, she would not 
have volunteered that she treated her partner's 4N as "Natura1". 
Arguably, without that self-incrimination, the ruling would have been 
in her favour. In the circumstances, I feel that an AMWM was a bit cruel.



More information about the blml mailing list