[blml] Correction of a revoke
Peter Eidt
PeterEidt at t-online.de
Wed Jan 2 20:54:45 CET 2008
> > From: Konrad Ciborowski
> >
> > [snip]
> >
> >> Am I supposed to ask my opponents
> >> to show me their hands every single time I claim?
> >> If they say "what for?" am I supposed to call the
> >> TD?
> >>
> >> It hardly seems practical. And it would annoy
> >> the hell out of everybody if I started doing it.
> >
> > Peter:
> > What about Law 66D ??
> >
> > "After play ceases, the played and unplayed cards
> > may be inspected to settle a claim of a revoke, or
> > of the number of tricks won or lost; [...]"
> >
> +=+ Er, well, Peter, what about it? If a revoke is found
> at that stage the Director's action conforms to the law
> operative at the stage at which the revoke is found.
> ~ Grattan ~ +=+
Peter:
Well, I only wanted to answer Konrad's question whether he is
allowed to ask his opponents to show their cards.
Yes, he is allowed to ask and "what for" and refusing is an
irregularity.
It was only secondarily related to 'our' revoke-threads.
More information about the blml
mailing list